In a company acquisition, the price is usually not a fixed number agreed and paid. It is a provisional number that is adjusted after closing, when the company’s actual accounts are prepared as at the closing date. That adjustment process is called completion accounts and it is the most widely used pricing mechanism in the Spanish market.
What are completion accounts
Completion accounts (also called closing accounts) are a post-closing price adjustment mechanism whereby:
- A provisional price is agreed based on estimates of net debt and working capital at the closing date.
- After closing, reference accounts are prepared as at the exact closing date.
- Actual values (real net debt, real working capital) are compared to the estimates.
- The difference adjusts the final price upward or downward.
It is a “settle later” mechanism: the parties close the deal at an estimated price and adjust it once they have the real numbers.
How it works step by step
Phase 1: Closing with provisional price
At closing, the buyer pays an estimated price based on:
- Agreed Enterprise Value (fixed, not adjusted)
- Estimated net debt at the closing date
- Estimated working capital vs. normalised working capital
Phase 2: Preparation of closing accounts
The buyer (typically) prepares a balance sheet as at the exact closing date, applying the accounting principles agreed in the SPA. Usual timeframe: 30-60 days after closing.
Phase 3: Seller review
The seller receives the accounts and has a period (15-30 days) to review them and submit objections.
Phase 4: Negotiation or arbitration
If there is disagreement, the parties negotiate. If they cannot reach agreement, an independent auditor (usually a Big Four or other previously agreed firm) resolves the disputed items. Their decision is binding.
Phase 5: Price adjustment
The difference between the provisional price paid and the final price per the closing accounts is calculated. If the final price is higher, the buyer pays the difference to the seller. If lower, the seller returns the difference (or it is deducted from the escrow).
Completion accounts vs. locked box
| Aspect | Completion accounts | Locked box |
|---|
| Price adjustment | Post-closing | No post-closing adjustment |
| Price certainty | Low until settlement | High from signing |
| Economic risk | Seller’s until closing, buyer’s after | Buyer’s from reference date |
| Post-closing complexity | High | Low |
| Common disputes | Frequent | Infrequent (except leakage) |
| Seller preference | Lower | Higher |
| Buyer preference | Higher | Lower |
Why they are chosen in the Spanish mid-market
Completion accounts are the dominant mechanism in Spain because:
- Buyers prefer paying based on actual data, not estimates.
- In mid-sized companies, financial information may not be robust enough for a locked box.
- Spanish advisers and lawyers are more familiar with this mechanism.
- The gap between signing and closing in many Spanish transactions is long (regulatory approvals, third-party consents), making it risky to fix the price in advance.
A practical example
An engineering company in southern Spain is sold at an Enterprise Value of 15 million. Normalised working capital is 2.8 million.
At closing (provisional price):
- Enterprise Value: 15M
- Estimated net debt: -3.2M
- Estimated working capital: 2.8M (equal to normalised, no adjustment)
- Provisional price: 11.8M
Closing accounts (45 days later):
- Actual net debt: -3.5M (300K more than estimated due to an undisclosed loan)
- Actual working capital: 2.4M (400K less than normalised)
Adjustment:
- Net debt: -300K (seller returns 300K)
- Working capital: -400K (seller returns 400K)
- Final price: 11.1M (700K less than provisional)
Frequently asked questions
How long does the completion accounts process take?
Typically 60 to 90 days from closing. The buyer prepares the accounts, the seller reviews them, and if disputes arise, an independent auditor resolves them. The process can be extended if discrepancies are significant.
Who prepares the closing accounts?
Usually the buyer, because they control the company after closing. The seller has the right to access the accounting information, review the accounts, and dispute any item they consider incorrect.
Do completion accounts generate many disputes?
Yes. It is one of the mechanisms that generates the most litigation in M&A. Disputes typically focus on classifications (is it debt or working capital?), accounting principles (which depreciation policy applies?), and provisions (are they sufficient?). A well-drafted SPA with clear accounting principles significantly reduces dispute risk.
Related articles