Every December I dedicate time to reflecting on what the year has taught me. Not about the numbers — those speak for themselves — but about qualitative lessons that determine the quality of future decisions. 2023 has been an interesting year — not the easiest or most profitable, but one of the most instructive.
Lesson 1: Patience has a measurable financial value
In a rising-rate, valuation-adjusting environment, patient investors achieved better entry prices than those who rushed in 2021-2022. Companies selling at 8x EBITDA two years ago are now at 6x. On a company with 3 million EBITDA, that two-point difference is 6 million euros. Patience is worth money — though it carries opportunity cost. The key is distinguishing strategic patience from analysis paralysis.
Lesson 2: Selectivity matters more in difficult markets
In 2021, almost any company with positive EBITDA found a buyer. In 2023, we evaluated more deals than ever but closed fewer — not from lack of opportunity, but from raising the bar. We prioritised revenue quality, client diversification, team quality, and thesis clarity. We turned down deals we would likely have done in 2021. No regrets.
Lesson 3: The team is everything
2023 confirmed this with special intensity. Portfolio companies that best navigated the year’s difficulties — cost inflation, margin pressure, demand uncertainty — were those with strong management teams. In two portfolio companies, we brought in key managers this year with immediate and significant impact.
Lesson 4: Active management makes the difference
In a difficult year, the gap between actively managed and autopilot companies widens. Companies where we worked actively on cost control, commercial improvement, and operational efficiency maintained or improved margins. Those that received less attention suffered more.
Lesson 5: Succession is now
The flow of succession-driven deals has grown significantly. More entrepreneurs than ever are contacting us. This flow will be the primary source of middle-market investment opportunities for the coming decade.
Lesson 6: Honesty is profitable
In every negotiation, in every due diligence, in every board meeting, honesty generates trust. This year we walked away from a deal after months of work because we discovered the seller had not been transparent about a material contingency. A difficult decision — costly in the short term — but the right one. Reputation is built with the nos as much as with the yeses.
Looking to 2024
We are moderately optimistic. The macroeconomic environment remains uncertain, but opportunities in the Spanish middle market are abundant and high-quality. Our portfolio is in good shape. Our team is strengthened. And our investment thesis — patient capital, active management, Spanish middle-market focus — is more relevant than ever.
Dirk Manuel Martens Jimenez
Founder, Blue Mountain Capital