When a company is in financial difficulty but still has a chance of survival, it needs time. Time to negotiate with creditors, restructure debt, and design a viable plan. Pre-insolvency is exactly that: a temporary shield that Spanish law grants to the debtor to attempt resolving their problems outside of formal insolvency proceedings.
What is pre-insolvency
Pre-insolvency — technically called “notification of the opening of negotiations” under Article 583 of the Spanish Insolvency Act (Texto Refundido de la Ley Concursal, TRLC) — is a formal filing made by the debtor before the competent commercial court, notifying that negotiations have begun with creditors to reach a restructuring plan or an agreement that avoids formal insolvency proceedings.
The main effect is the suspension of the obligation to file for insolvency and protection against involuntary insolvency petitions (filed by creditors) for a period of three months, extendable by one additional month.
Effects of pre-insolvency
Protection for the debtor
- Suspension of the obligation to file for insolvency. The debtor is not required to file for voluntary insolvency during the negotiation period, even if technically insolvent.
- Block on involuntary insolvency petitions. Creditors cannot petition for insolvency proceedings while the protection is in effect.
- Possibility of requesting a stay of enforcement. The debtor may ask the court to stay individual enforcement actions against assets necessary for continuing the business.
Obligations of the debtor
- Negotiate in good faith with creditors.
- Refrain from asset dispositions that would prejudice creditors.
- Report the outcome of negotiations to the court within the prescribed period.
When to use pre-insolvency
Pre-insolvency is the appropriate tool when:
- The company is operationally viable but has a debt problem (over-leverage, unsustainable maturities, loss of credit facilities).
- The main creditors have a genuine willingness to negotiate.
- Time is needed to prepare a viability plan or restructuring plan.
- The publicity and stigma of formal insolvency proceedings should be avoided.
It is not the right tool when:
- The company is not operationally viable (irrecoverable structural losses).
- It is used as a mere delaying tactic with no real intention to negotiate.
- Insolvency is so severe there is no room for negotiation.
Pre-insolvency in the M&A context
For Blue Mountain and investors in distressed companies, pre-insolvency creates a window of opportunity:
-
For the investor: A company in pre-insolvency is open to solutions that include new capital. An investor can negotiate the acquisition of the company or an equity injection as part of the restructuring plan, typically on favourable terms.
-
For the company: The entry of a solvent investor can be the missing piece for creditors to accept the restructuring plan. New capital demonstrates future viability and aligns incentives.
-
For the creditors: They prefer a restructuring plan that preserves value (even if it involves haircuts or deferrals) to formal insolvency proceedings where recovery rates are typically much lower.
A practical example
A construction company in Madrid with 40 million in revenue enters difficulty when its main client (a property developer) defaults on 6 million. With 12 million in financial debt and maturities within the next 60 days that it cannot service, the company files a pre-insolvency notification.
During the three months of protection:
- It negotiates with its three bank creditors a restructuring: 12-month payment holiday, term extension to 7 years, and a 15% haircut.
- Blue Mountain evaluates the company and offers a 3 million equity injection in exchange for a 40% stake, conditional on approval of the restructuring plan.
- The plan is presented to the court as a sanctionable restructuring plan. The banks accept it (representing more than 75% of the debt).
The company avoids formal insolvency, the banks recover more than they would in liquidation, and Blue Mountain enters a viable company at an attractive valuation.
Frequently asked questions
How long does the pre-insolvency protection last?
Three months from the filing, extendable by one additional month. The debtor must use that time to actively negotiate with creditors. At the end of the period, they must have reached an agreement or file for formal insolvency.
Is the pre-insolvency filing public?
No. The filing is not published in the Public Insolvency Register or the official gazette. Only the court has knowledge. However, creditors being negotiated with will necessarily be aware of the situation, and in practice information may leak in smaller markets.
What happens when the pre-insolvency period expires?
The debtor must have reached a restructuring plan (court-sanctioned if necessary) or filed for formal insolvency proceedings if insolvency persists. If no action is taken, any creditor can petition for involuntary insolvency.
Related articles